A 22-year-old woman in Spain has had her dismissal upheld by the Social Court of Alicante after she was fired from her job for repeatedly arriving at work approximately 40 minutes before her official start time, despite receiving numerous warnings over two years.
The employee had been specifically instructed not to arrive between 6:45 a.m. and 7:00 a.m., as her work schedule officially began at 7:30 a.m., and she was also told she was not permitted to clock in or begin work early. However, she continued to arrive well before her shift with no assigned duties.
Her employer eventually terminated her appointment for what the company described as serious misconduct, arguing that her persistent early arrival amounted to disobedience rather than dedication, as she was directly defying explicit workplace instructions. The woman challenged the decision, claiming the dismissal was unfair.
During the hearing, judges were told that the woman had ignored several verbal and written warnings and had arrived early on at least 19 different occasions. Evidence also showed that on some days, she attempted to log into the company system using a mobile app before she had even reached the office.
The employer further accused her of breaching trust by selling a used company car battery without authorization.
The court sided with the company, stressing that the issue was not excessive punctuality but a deliberate and repeated refusal to follow workplace rules. The judges held that her conduct constituted a serious breach under Article 54 of the Spanish Workers’ Statute, which governs disciplinary dismissals.
While the woman still has the option of appealing to the Supreme Court of Valencia, the judgment currently stands.





