A man who was left just S$1 in his mother’s will has lost his legal battle to have the document declared invalid, with the court ruling that the will was properly executed and legally valid.
The case was heard at the Family Justice Courts Singapore, where the plaintiff, the youngest of three sons, attempted to challenge the final will of his late mother. He sought to reinstate an earlier will that would have allowed a flat and other assets to pass to his daughter instead.
However, the court ruled against him and ordered that he pay legal costs of nearly S$75,000 to his aunt, who was named as the main beneficiary and executor of the will.
According to the judgment delivered by District Judge Cassandra Cheong, the deceased woman had made three wills in 2018, 2019 and 2020. Each version left only S$1 to each of her three sons, though the distribution of other assets differed.
In the final will drafted in 2020, the woman left her Klang Lane HDB flat, Singapore to her second son, while the remaining assets, including money in her bank accounts and shares in Singtel, were left to her sister.
The sister was also appointed the sole executor and trustee of the will.
Court documents described the deceased as a strong-willed and independent woman who had raised her three sons alone after her first marriage ended in divorce in 1980.
She worked as a car park attendant to support the family before later remarrying in 1992 and helping her husband start a scaffolding business. In 2004, she started her own maid employment agency in Singapore, specialising in recruiting domestic helpers from India.
The judge noted that the woman had faced significant challenges with her sons over the years. Her eldest son was declared bankrupt after running into debt and was accused of forging her signature to sell two of her properties. The second son had previously served time in prison for drug-related offences before later turning his life around.
The plaintiff, who filed the lawsuit, was described by the court as the son who caused the greatest concern to the deceased. According to the judgment, he had a troubled history that included time in a boys’ home, failed marriages, unsuccessful businesses, and criminal convictions.
The dispute also involved the man’s daughter, who had lived with her grandmother for several years while growing up. The grandmother had taken care of her expenses and education, even enrolling her in dance, singing, and swimming classes.
However, tensions later arose within the family after jewellery went missing from the woman’s home in 2019. The deceased suspected that her granddaughter may have been influenced by the plaintiff to steal the items and filed a police report.
Judge Cheong said evidence showed that the woman herself had initiated the drafting of the 2020 will and had approached her sister for help finding a lawyer.
The plaintiff argued that his aunt had manipulated his mother into changing her will in order to inherit assets believed to be worth more than S$5 million.
But the judge dismissed the claim, describing the allegations as unsupported.
“The deceased was not a weak-willed elderly lady who was ignorant in relation to the workings of a will,” Judge Cheong said in her ruling.
“She was a feisty, independent and strong-willed woman and a well-known businesswoman in the Little India area.”
The court concluded that the woman understood the contents of the 2020 will and signed it voluntarily.
As a result, the judge declared the will valid and ruled that the aunt has the legal right to apply for probate based on the document. The plaintiff has since filed an appeal against the decision.





